Chevalier, Colonel Monro and Haytham- I bet Shay had sex with each of them. With Chevalier it would be rough and angry, with Monro- sweet, passionate and comforting, while with Haytham… well. There would be a lot of power play, with Haytham winning every time and Shay secretly loving it. Or maybe not so secretly, judging by his moans. >:D